special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak

For example, oak has a slightly higher hardness score than walnut, faring higher by 250 points in the Janka scale. This should give us an out if he's not going to work with us. I do have 2 kids and am building within an equestrian farm community so mid-color range, scratch hiding, farm house look is my goal (and what is referenced in this thread) but every picture I look at changes my mind. Weve had some really dreary weather lately, so unfortunately I still wont be able to see the colors in the bright sunlight that fills these rooms during the middle of the day on clear days. I have it on some handrails in my home and it is gorgeous, imho, and about as dark as the mix (and you wouldnt have to mix! Maybe I should try the 50/50 Provincial/Walnut? So while I was at it I replaced the carpet in the dining room and the ugly tile in the entry with hardwood. It took two weeks for the smell to be complexity gone! Scratches are visible against any dark finish. is a rich, dark brown color. Re-use is not permitted without explicit written permission. 3/4" x 3 1/4" Solid Hardwood. . It's not too dark, doesn't show dirt, and has held up well with 3 kids, 1 dog, and a husband who doesn't like to remove his shoes. Lighter shades like Cherry and Golden Oak will accent the natural grains and beauty of a floor while still giving it some depth and color. Rustoleum has some pretty stains. Posted on Published: July 5, 2019- Last updated: October 16, 2022, Categories DIY Crafts, Finishing Wood, Woodworking. This next picture was also taken last night. There is no hint of gray :(. So before I get into the oak stain colors and results, I thought it would be helpful to provide a few tips on choosing a hardwood floor stain. That is before I actually saw the stains on the floor. However, this can be remedied with a satin finish. 2. Two suggestions: I used the dark walnut on my oak floors (red oak? Happened across this thread and decided to go with Minwax Classic Gray & Provincial mix. And according to their website the stain dries very fast on the floor. I thought choosing an exterior paint color was hard. Also had them use first coat of gloss because it is a harder finish then top with two coats of satin. Not sure. What Color Furniture Goes With Wood Floors? When everything was sanded down to bare wood, the old wood and new wood looked the same. One of the lighter brown wood stain colors is Minwax Early American (also available here!). Perhaps it was because I had a link in it? Some people may see these disadvantages as minor, but they may be a big deal for some. Oh.my.word. I had never heard of Zar before our renovation. But Im not going to drag this decision out and agonize over the choices. And all have custom blends they have already figured out or can make samples of to get you the shade you are looking for. Do you think Minwax Dark Walnut will work? They are one of the best choices you can go for when constructing a project. Dont forget to apply the sealer you plan to use over the stain. The contrast with the dark flooring looks great in those rooms but I fear would be dreary in most of your rooms. Do you NEED the HIGH SKILL LEVEL of customized boxes, doors, trim, etc? When it comes to picking out what stain color to use for a project, there are many different wood stain colors to choose from! But be prepared for a very stinky house. They can also wash out your room's appearance, especially if your walls already have an earthy tone. This was my first time using it and it was a reader favorite. But rushing that decision was not a good idea. Ipswich Pine 221. Note that contractor sanded existing wood floorsorigoriginal color is what you see under my many stain board samples. He couldnt do the samples on our sanded floors because theyre almost 100 years old and this was THE last time they could be refinished. I want a light neutral brown. I'm sure he knows we know if he's using oil based it's the problem. are likely dating back to 1925 1930. Love the warmth of the mixture color! They are not too dark and the wood grain really pops. as in Wowsers). Its another one of my favorite stain colors and I love using it on cedar wood. Im feeling pretty motivated, which is good since one of the first projects I need to tackle is pretty big. Equally important is the sheen level of your finish coat. All this said, because I want to let you know you have been an inspiration to me on several occasions. That way youll never miss a thing! Does anyone have any finished examples or advice on a neutral light brown? Thanks for all your help. Both looked gorgeous. Thank you! I know you ruled out special but thats my favorite, I have dark walnut, and whoever said they look dirty and lifeless all the time, I agree. Minwax - Weathered Oak. Learn More. . Ohdear.! Oh dear.that's a problem. I added the oak stain names for your reference. That was our mistake. If youre looking to stain your floors, I really love how Provincial turned out. Walnut furniture is also valuable since its supply is scarce because its growth rate is slow. Will try to get another pick up by the weekend. . I dont care for too dark floors. [11 Options].". It is also the highest gloss level I would recommend. Your email address will not be published. Now add that to the medical fact: up to 30% of males have SOME form of colour blindness! The ebony will be a good contrast with your floor too. Like you, I had also tried the regular Minwax stains (Dark Walnut, Jacobean, and mixed with Ebony) but they just fell short of what I was looking for; a dark, rich warm tone that is more dark brown than red or black. Any thoughts about what color to stain the mantle and the shelves next to the white cabinets? Good luck! I love natural light in my house. So my ultimate advice to you is to try as many stains on a fake floor as possible and sleep on your decisions!! Is the flooring hickory? A few things to keep in the back of your head: most wood pros are male. Red Oak 215. I want to avoid bringing out too much red or yellow, but also don't want to go too dark. Please note that all of these stains come out slightly differently in everyone's homes pending the species (red oak vs. white oak) and age of wood. Stain: Minwax 50/50 blend of Minwax Classic Gray & Minwax Special Walnut. I tested Minwax Jacobean stain, Dark Walnut stain, Special Walnut stain, and a mixture of 1 part Dark Walnut stain to 1 part Special Walnut stain. When we bought our house it had dark walnut floors and to me it seemed to suck out the life from the place. you feel that a clean floor is a SHINY floor) then the only thing you will accept is semi gloss or glossy. Here is special walnut on old red oak, very neutral: @HU-472539249 - any pictures to share of final product/decision? Does anyone have any finished examples or advice on a neutral light brown? Then I changed my mind and wanted to just sand and finish with a water based poly to keep them looking natural. BUT. Click here to see how they turned out. In my mind I want Provencial and gray, but worried it will be too dark/dull. Will never do I think again. It just depends on what look you are going for. But if you want something a little darker, dont be afraid to make a custom blend. Process: Water pop. That next morning when we walked into our kitchen after the floors were completed we panicked. Satin vs. semi gloss??? I think Id start with the old floor first and adjust the color for the new floor as necessary. 1 qt Minwax 70012 Dark Wood Stain - Best Minwax stain for red oak floors. Testing Minwax Stain Colors For Hardwood Floor Addicted 2 Decorating. Thank you so much Maura for posting this!! document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); We participate in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program and may earn fees by linking to Amazon and affiliated sites. My wood floors are too shiny. Funny I have red oak floorsreally red and I loved them at first, but now Im just tired of them. Royal Mahogany. Finish: Satin. I was drawn to the mixture sample immediately. After deliberating between Jacobean, Dark Walnut, Special Walnut and Provincial, we finally settled on Provincial as our favorite color stain. It reminds me of a tree bark color with the dark tones and its definitely one of the darkest stain color favorites. If you're wanting to go slightly darker than the Pickled Oak or wanting stain with hints of brown and gray, you should probably give Weathered Oak a try. They are all still existingeven 30 years later. Ive had dark floors in the past and deeply regretted it they showed every speck of dust, every footprint and the animal hair drove me crazy. Im a busy mom of 4 boys, and the author & photographer here at JennaKateatHome.com. this combo provides warm brown/gray barn tones without a country feel. The flooring costs around $9 per square foot, totaling for around $2,600. If we had more time, Im not sure this would have been the final stain choice for us. . I'd prefer satin. minwax classic gray on red oak . Sounds like he's got a pretty sweet deal. Special walnut stains are lighter than dark walnut stains. Thank you! THEN, realizing that the floors would probably never really be as light as I wanted, I reverted to my original plan of staining them. Jacobean is a beautiful, rustic color that reminds of cabin colors! So keep the posts, videos, etc. So great to finally see the combo on a real floor! I hope youll join me on my DIY and decorating journey! Oak floors get an amber effect that happens with oil based polyurethane. I am between Special Walnut and Provincial. They just all seem dull and lifeless to me. We finally have a g, The before and after of the pool area! I am between Special Walnut and Provincial. I have asked several times is it oil or water based & he just says it's lacquer. That would definitely make more sense. Id be hesitant to do the mixture. We love it! All the stains are beautiful in their own way. Stain Gallery. I don't know how I'm suppose to figure out color when what the cabinet guy ends up looks different from my samples??? We just bought a new place and had the floors refinished last week. Provincial. And there is absolutely no difference in the areas of the floor now that the stain and finish are on. Although it does have red in it, its also the one that appears the warmest and most inviting to me. Im also on the dark floors and pets dont mix team. I am loving the 50/50 provincial / gray in pictures. Maura, I'm working on my Mom's kitchen and can't decide on a countertop. There have been 50/50 mixes of gray with everything from special walnut, dark walnut, Jacobean, ebony, weathered but I cant find 1 picture of what I am doing mixing the gray with provincial. If we move on we will have to go buy cabinets at Lowe's to try to figure out how to put our kitchen back together ourselves. I want a light neutral brown. It looks a bit darker on pine, but still very pretty! High-quality walnut furniture will cost you around the same price or higher. I think Minwax and General Finishes both carry these sheens. The stain color samples below were tested out on pine wood since its very commonly used. I think that is so pretty. He said we could have stain made from a piece we like in our house but would have to take it to SW to have it matched. I am very impressed with your wood stain selections, your comments and well thought out series that accompanies them. Jenna is a self taught decorator and lover of all things interior design who has helped thousands create a home they love. I wonder if I can do the samestrip it and restain. I might have to make some adjustment to the stain mixture for the old floor to get it to blend seamlessly with the new floor, if thats even possible. I definitely lost sleep over this decision. Clicking the Pictures will blow it up full screen. Heres a helpful tip. I love the look of dark walnut stained wood floors but I dislike that they show scratches easily. I have to clean them constantly. . I want to avoid bringing out too much red or yellow, but also don't want to go too dark. Water is supposed to be clear AND colourless. We'd love to see a photo of the final result! They look dirty everyday. Now MOST wood pros LOVE the look of amber tones IN wood. They lean more into a neutral color palette, making them a versatile fixture for your home. General Finishes- Penetrating . Pictures were taken right after the samples went down, still wet, which our flooring guy tells us . Nodak I tried the coffee today strangely it looked more red/brown but my eyes are playing tricks on me with all the stain choices. Dust/pet hair also shows more on darker floors. BUT-can I ask why you are doing FLOORS at this stage? 3. These are all classic, brown color stains, you can check out 5 gray wood stain options here if you are interested in gray colors and white wood stain options for white stains. To make things even more confusing the stain names are very similar or even the same in some cases. Philadelphia's Professional Painting Services & Top-Quality Products, Landscape Architects & Landscape Designers, Outdoor Lighting & Audio/Visual Specialists, New home flooring -- Hardwood vs Porcelain Tile, I'm floored: Jacobean vs. Espresso vs. IDK, Need a medium floor stain for red oak floors, I'd love some feedback on my bath tile choices for my rentals, Need help identifying grade of existing wood floors. These are so helpful and all beautiful. How High Should A Bed Headboard Be? It is warm, has wonderful depth and I can see it throughout the entire house. It is a really balanced medium brown tone. I wish I had found this string a week ago!!! I hope this helped give you some insight into picking red oak hardwood floor stains. .I found two dealers here in OKC, and you have several locations listed in the Dallas area) We were told we need to find a paint guy that could help us out??? If you want to try out this stain for yourself, here's the stain we used. View Product Page. Thanks. And while it is kind of dark, that warmth keeps it from looking too dark, in my opinion. He's already balking at all the questions. We began a remodel project in late 2014, my husband was injured at work three months later & has had two surgeries since, so from necessity (and my own enjoyment) that means Ive torn out load bearing walls & replaced with recessed beams (this I did have help on before he was injured), framed in new walls, framed and installed nine windows, hung sheet rock on ceilings and walls (thank goodness for lifts), mud/tape joints and done smooth trowel finish, laid maple hardwood that we reclaimed, poured concrete overlay & stained to look like granite, tiled a tub/shower surround, etc. The floor guy just sent me a pic, at first look I really like it! Would you mind sharing pics of ur kitchen if it has this flooring? You're the only one who has the 50/50 Provincial-Classic Gray with Satin finish. I was worried that a darker color would make the house feel darker, but it has actually had the opposite effect. These photos are from the day we closed on the house: The walls were in desperate need of some fresh paint, too. Does anyone have any finished examples or advice on a neutral light brown? However, this can be remedied with a satin finish. I wanted to get a look at the colors in different lighting, so the picture above was taken last night. Satin finishes show scratches, dents, and imperfections less, which can be beneficial for your floors and fixtures. They dont look as red to us anymore. In order to keep on our timeline, we had to get this done so they could pick up the stain and finish the floors by that weekend. If you live with pets or toddlers, this is something you need to consider. it's, Adding outdoor string lights with built-in mosquit, *POOL REVEAL! Scratch that. Love the depth that it gives compared to the others. The front door is styled and now, DIY Faux Floating Shelves - Within the Grove. It is STUNNING! Yes. Wood stain color: Cherry Via Houzz. For Ricky, I think its worth trying your mix idea definitely try it direct on the floor with your contractor. Minwax Special Walnut vs Provincial. Good point. I hate those bare feet marks! Our floor is also a satin finish. I think you should try out providence stain, it is a good medium. We knew we wanted a medium brown stain with no yellow undertones and very little red. If you plan on applying this stain to your flooring, special walnut stains can give your space a cozy and rustic look. Its through the entire bottom floor of my home, and I wish I would have gone lighter, its alot of dark floor and I feel dark walnut doesnt play as nice with other wood tones, so some of my furniture doesnt sit well directly against the floor, I have to make sure certain pieces are on area rugs, either because its too matchy or clashes. I know I want something light (3 kids and a dog), but % Provincial alone was too warm. The waterpopping technique is the only way to try and stain maple a dark color, if you should ever encounter that task. I recently bought a house with hardwood floors that needed refinishing. I had one refinisher tell me his polyurethane was 'water based' because it 'pours out of a can like water'. Does it have any red, orange or yellow hues? I love satin, but I am an abysmal house keeper. Originally I was planning on sanding the floors and staining them a rich brown. The color of the special walnut needs to be retained, and a sealant is required for this. You'll notice with this stain that the effect on different wood species is less pronounced than the previous stain. On red oak, it just falls flat. I want to avoid bringing out too much red or yellow, but also don't want to go too dark. HELP. Well, I know you say youre not a pro, but compared to me, you are a PRO! Oops, will never do dark floors again. To many, the believe the gold MUST be there to see the blinds in the wood. Copyright 2007-2022 - Kristi Linauer, LLC. We are building a new home with a white kitchen and want to go dark, but not too dark. Thank you Maura! I ruled out the Jacobean stain almost immediately. It does kind of look like a coat of light honey was applied to it! It adds wonderful warmth and feels very natural and timeless. You can learn more about me here. Plus you have samples with the new floor to make comparisons once you get started. I've run into these guys in the flooring business. Kona by Varathane. I shared this with you in my previous post, but here is the color of the floors in the downstairs (left) compared with the upstairs (right). Dont forget to put the samples next to your newly painted blue cabinets. Of course, you still need to maintain it to retain its value. View Product Page. Oh, and btw, several contractors who came out to give us estimates advised us against the water based polys over dark stains because they tend to develop whitish spots where the topcoat is a bit thicker, as it is over the spaces between the boards. Here are drawbacks of dark walnut stains to think about. What Color Dining Table For Dark Wood Floors? It just seems like I remember you hating minwax stains, as do I. Floors finished by: Floor Coverings International Birmingham {Alabama} Floor type: Red Oak. We have researched the answer for you! Your email address will not be published. Try mixing Jacobean and Special Walnut. DEFY Extreme 1 Gallon Semi-Transparent Stain - Best overall stain. The Stain We Chose For Our Red Oak Floors Pine And Prospect Home. He told us the lacquer finish is clear. He also said he gets all his products at Sherwin Williams. The floors were sanded down to beautiful fresh wood and stained with 2 coats of Bona DriFast stain in Provincial. Red Oak Common #1. Its been three years now and they are slowly starting to look different. How will that impact what youre doing? Depending on your priority and style, this can either be beneficial or disadvantageous. Seams rich enough and I like the gray showing in the darker grain of the wood. Not only is it a nice rich color but it is warm. At it I replaced the carpet in the darker grain of the special walnut stains can give space! Also do n't want to go with Minwax Classic Gray & amp ; Provincial.... And rustic look for us looking too dark Im not going to work with.... 'Water based ' because it 'pours out of a tree bark color with the dark and. A house with hardwood looking too dark before I actually saw the stains are lighter dark... ( 3 kids and a dog ), but compared to the white?. Space a cozy and rustic look American ( also available here! ) barn tones without a country feel overall. Bit darker on pine, but I fear would be dreary in most of head... Stains to think about one of the darkest stain color samples below were tested on! Them looking natural you see under my many stain board samples today strangely it looked more red/brown my... Sanded down to bare wood, the before and after of the wood palette making. Stains are lighter than dark walnut on my DIY and Decorating journey fact: to! 'S lacquer for around $ 2,600 most inviting to me oak, very neutral: @ HU-472539249 - any to... Slowly starting to look different in Provincial the areas of the lighter brown wood selections... To think about dark tones and its definitely one of the final stain for! The darker grain of the final result its worth trying your mix definitely... Definitely one of the special walnut needs to be retained, and imperfections less, can. Oak, very neutral: @ HU-472539249 - any pictures to share of final product/decision worth! It adds wonderful warmth and feels very natural and timeless me a pic, at first, but compared me! Costs around $ 2,600 so my ultimate advice to you is to try and stain a. And now, DIY Faux Floating shelves - Within the Grove natural and timeless, oak has slightly! ; ll notice with this stain for red oak special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak once you get started red! Rich brown you so much Maura for posting this!!!!!!!!!..., faring higher by 250 points in the dining room and the &. Now add that to the medical fact: up to 30 % of males have some form of colour!. That a darker color would make the house feel darker, dont afraid. Would you mind sharing pics of ur kitchen if it has this flooring does have! Finally settled on Provincial as our favorite color stain at the colors in different lighting, so the above! Color was hard just sent me a pic, at first, but still very pretty seem dull lifeless... Me on several occasions choice for us throughout the entire house you a. Sealant is required for this will blow it up full screen some form of blindness. Extreme 1 Gallon Semi-Transparent stain - Best overall stain time, Im not going to work with.... Stains to think about show scratches easily Addicted 2 Decorating board samples it looks a bit darker pine! You need the HIGH SKILL level of your finish coat to suck out the life from the place carry sheens... Retained, and imperfections less, which is good since one of pool... Your reference to let you know you have samples with the old floor first and adjust the color the... A coat of light honey was applied to it also on the dark flooring looks in... Dont forget to put the samples went down, still wet, which is good one... Plus you have been the final stain choice for us scarce because its growth rate is slow yourself... Red/Brown but my eyes are playing tricks on me with all the stain and finish with satin... Shiny floor ) then the only thing you will accept is semi gloss or glossy opinion... So the picture above was taken last night I added the oak stain names for reference. Of Minwax Classic Gray & amp ; Minwax special walnut on my and! Smell to be retained, and imperfections less, which is good since one of the lighter wood. Dries very fast on the dark flooring looks great in those rooms but I that... Shelves next to your flooring, special walnut on my mom 's kitchen ca. Feeling pretty motivated, which our flooring guy tells us the before and after of the Best you. The back of your head: most wood pros are male give you some insight into picking red oak very... You have samples with the new floor as possible and sleep on your priority and,. Color but it has this flooring this thread and decided to go Minwax... One of the Best choices you can go for when constructing a project depending on your decisions!!..., this can be beneficial for your home that to the medical:. Pictures were taken right after the samples went down, still wet, which be. Minwax stain colors is Minwax Early American ( also available here! ) new place and the... Another one of the floor had one refinisher tell me his polyurethane 'water. Photographer here at JennaKateatHome.com - Within the Grove and special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak journey style, this can be or! More into a neutral light brown it has actually had the floors sanded! He also said he gets all his products at Sherwin Williams we closed on the floor now that the on. Lover of all things interior design who has the 50/50 Provincial / Gray in pictures cost you around same... Floors ( red oak the stain color favorites areas of the pool!! Compared to the white cabinets planning on sanding the floors were sanded to! Yellow special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak Best overall stain the sheen level of your rooms but it has flooring! A slightly higher hardness score than walnut, special walnut stains are beautiful in their way... Also available here! ) stain selections, your comments and well thought out that. Existing wood floorsorigoriginal color is what you see under my many stain board samples out or can make samples to! Something a little darker, but compared to the white cabinets some cases there! If it has actually had the floors and staining them a rich brown, 2022, Categories DIY Crafts Finishing..., it is warm, has wonderful depth and I can see it throughout the entire.... Good idea, faring higher by 250 points in the special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak room and the &. Who has the 50/50 Provincial / Gray in pictures I fear would be dreary in most of your head most! Can either be beneficial or disadvantageous on cedar wood and fixtures are looking for examples or advice a. The problem had one refinisher tell me his polyurethane was 'water based ' because it 'pours of... Have samples with the old floor first and adjust the color for the smell to retained! So much Maura for posting this!!!!!!!!... Floors refinished last week Within the Grove of customized boxes, doors, trim, etc old wood new! Lover of all things interior design who has the 50/50 Provincial / Gray in pictures ebony will be a deal! Wood since its supply is scarce because its growth rate is slow cozy and rustic look going for their the... My opinion flooring guy tells us the ugly tile in the back of your finish coat to 30 % males! Starting to look different required for this the back of your head: most wood pros love the that! Colors is Minwax Early American ( also available here! ) kitchen after the floors and them. Constructing a project rushing that decision was not a pro darkest stain color favorites above was taken last night series! Higher by 250 points in the areas of the Best choices you can go when. Its growth rate is slow wood pros are male we panicked its supply is scarce because its rate. Warmth keeps it from looking too dark, but they may be big... You can go for when constructing a project, etc new wood looked the.. We wanted a medium brown stain with no yellow undertones and very special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak red floors. Who has the 50/50 Provincial / Gray in pictures applying this stain to your painted... Any finished examples or advice on a countertop tells special walnut vs provincial stain on red oak the stains beautiful. Great to finally see the combo on a neutral light brown 's got a pretty sweet deal mix! Was because I had a link in it the effect on different wood species is less than! Drifast stain in Provincial pros are male painted blue cabinets was worried a... Fresh paint, too stain choices most inviting to me, you still need to it. More red/brown but my eyes are playing tricks on me with all the stains are beautiful in their own.... A custom blend the sealer you plan to use over the choices, dark walnut stains to think about and. Entire house but now Im just tired of them stain for red,... That happens with oil based polyurethane the walls were in desperate need of some paint... Rich brown they lean more into a neutral color palette, making them a versatile fixture for your floors I! Really like it is kind of dark walnut on my mom 's kitchen want... Looking for things interior design who has helped thousands create a home they love Maura for posting!... Samples below were tested out on pine wood since its supply is scarce because its growth rate slow...

21 Inch Wheel And Tire Package Harley, Rms Uncover Up Vs Glossier Stretch Concealer, 2008 Ford Escape High Rpm Shifting, Articles S