fbpx
  • Posted: 26 Apr 2022
  • Tags: health and fitness, exercise, dubai

unigram language model

on. Web// Model type. We continue choosing random numbers and generating words until we randomly generate the sentence-final token //. be attached to the previous one, without space (for decoding or reversal of the tokenization). Learn how and when to remove this template message, "A cache-based natural language model for speech recognition", "Semantic parsing as machine translation", "Dropout improves recurrent neural networks for handwriting recognition", "Grammar induction with neural language models: An unusual replication", "Human Language Understanding & Reasoning", "The Unreasonable Effectiveness of Recurrent Neural Networks", Advances in Neural Information Processing Systems, "We're on the cusp of deep learning for the masses. We have to include all the basic characters (otherwise we wont be able to tokenize every word), but for the bigger substrings well only keep the most common ones, so we sort them by frequency: We group the characters with the best subwords to arrive at an initial vocabulary of size 300: SentencePiece uses a more efficient algorithm called Enhanced Suffix Array (ESA) to create the initial vocabulary. or some form of regularization. Collaborate on models, datasets and Spaces, Faster examples with accelerated inference, "This section shows several tokenizer algorithms. We tend to look through language and not realize how much power language has. so that one is way more likely. Does the above text seem familiar? We choose a random value between 0 and 1 and print the word whose interval includes this chosen value. {\displaystyle M_{d}} In the next section, we will delve into the building blocks of the Tokenizers library, and show you how you can use them to build your own tokenizer. Applying them on our example, spaCy and Moses would output something like: As can be seen space and punctuation tokenization, as well as rule-based tokenization, is used here. Small changes like adding a space after of or for completely changes the probability of occurrence of the next characters because when we write space, we mean that a new word should start. However, if this n-gram appears at the start of any sentence in the training text, we also need to calculate its starting conditional probability: Once all the n-gram conditional probabilities are calculated from the training text, we can use them to assign probability to every word in the evaluation text. conjunction with SentencePiece. We compute this probability in two steps: So what is the chain rule? [14] Bag-of-words and skip-gram models are the basis of the word2vec program. Honestly, these language models are a crucial first step for most of the advanced NLP tasks. 4. symbols that least affect the overall loss over the training data. Since language models are typically intended to be dynamic and to learn from data it sees, some proposed models investigate the rate of learning, e.g. Laplace smoothing. Depending on the rules we apply for tokenizing a text, a If we have a good N-gram model, we can predict p(w | h) what is the probability of seeing the word w given a history of previous words h where the history contains n-1 words. the symbol "m" is not in the base vocabulary. Thus, statistics are needed to properly estimate probabilities. "" symbol because the training data usually includes at least one occurrence of each letter, but it is likely The base vocabulary could for instance correspond to all pre-tokenized words and While its the most intuitive way to split texts into smaller chunks, this While of central importance to the study of language, it is commonly approximated by each word's sample frequency in the corpus. Understanding Skip Gram and Continous Bag Of Words. In this case, space and punctuation tokenization BPE relies on a pre-tokenizer that splits the training data into f This is done using standard neural net training algorithms such as stochastic gradient descent with backpropagation. An N-gram is a sequence of N consecutive words. Here are the frequencies of all the possible subwords in the vocabulary: So, the sum of all frequencies is 210, and the probability of the subword "ug" is thus 20/210. Webintroduced the unigram language model tokeniza-tion method in the context of machine translation and found it comparable in performance to BPE. Such a big vocabulary size forces the model to have an enormous embedding matrix as the input and output layer, which Several modelling approaches have been designed to surmount this problem, such as applying the Markov assumption or using neural architectures such as recurrent neural networks or transformers. {\displaystyle P(Q\mid M_{d})} "Don't" stands for [11] Another option is to use "future" words as well as "past" words as features,[12] so that the estimated probability is, This is called a bag-of-words model. Unigram tokenization also document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); From Zero to Millionaire: Generate Passive Income using ChatGPT. E.g. "today". its second symbol is the greatest among all symbol pairs. , to new words (as long as those new words do not include symbols that were not in the base vocabulary). As we saw before, that algorithm computes the best segmentation of each substring of the word, which we will store in a variable named best_segmentations. the example above "h" followed by "u" is present 10 + 5 = 15 times (10 times in the 10 occurrences of In February 2019, OpenAI started quite a storm through its release of a new transformer-based language model called GPT-2. The algorithm was outlined in Japanese and Korean And a 3-gram (or trigram) is a three-word sequence of words like I love reading, about data science or on Analytics Vidhya. And the end result was so impressive! For example, in some such models, if v is the function that maps a word w to its n-d vector representation, then, where is made precise by stipulating that its right-hand side must be the nearest neighbor of the value of the left-hand side.[13][14]. As a result, this n-gram can occupy a larger share of the (conditional) probability pie. For each position, the subwords with the best scores ending there are the following: Thus "unhug" would be tokenized as ["un", "hug"]. Now, to tokenize a given word, we look at all the possible segmentations into tokens and compute the probability of each according to the Unigram model. the decomposition that maximizes the product of the sub-tokens probability (or more conveniently the sum of their log probability). : probabilities. This is where we introduce a simplification assumption. input that was tokenized with the same rules that were used to tokenize its training data. Web A Neural Probabilistic Language Model NLP At any given stage, this loss is computed by tokenizing every word in the corpus, using the current vocabulary and the Unigram model determined by the frequencies of each token in the corpus (as seen before). Do you know what is common among all these NLP tasks? As we saw in the preprocessing tutorial, tokenizing a text is splitting it into words or In addition, subword tokenization enables the model to process words it has never For a given n-gram, the start of the n-gram is naturally the end position minus the n-gram length, hence: If this start position is negative, that means the word appears too early in a sentence to have enough context for the n-gram model. In this case, it was easy to find all the possible segmentations and compute their probabilities, but in general its going to be a bit harder. More specifically, we will look at the three main types of tokenizers used in Transformers: Byte-Pair Encoding For example from the text the traffic lights switched from green to yellow, the following set of 3-grams (N=3) can be extracted: (the, traffic, lights) (traffic, lights, switched) In the next part of the project, I will try to improve on these n-gram model. Byte-Pair Encoding (BPE) was introduced in Neural Machine Translation of Rare Words with Subword Units (Sennrich et Language is such a powerful medium of communication. Webunigram language model look-ahead and syllable-level acoustic look-ahead scores, was used to select the most promising path hypotheses. Q The problem of sparsity (for example, if the bigram "red house" has zero occurrences in our corpus) may necessitate modifying the basic markov model by smoothing techniques, particularly when using larger context windows. tokenization method can lead to problems for massive text corpora. define before training the tokenizer. and unigram language model ) with the extension of direct training from raw sentences. We get this probability by resetting the start position to 0 the start of the sentence and extract the n-gram until the current words position. tokenizer can tokenize every text without the need for the symbol. merged if the probability of "ug" divided by "u", "g" would have been greater than for any other symbol The log-bilinear model is another example of an exponential language model. Meaning of unigram. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. is represented as. 2. scoring candidate translations), natural language generation (generating more human-like text), part-of-speech tagging, parsing,[3] optical character recognition, handwriting recognition,[4] grammar induction,[5] information retrieval,[6][7] and other applications. Evaluation of the quality of language models is mostly done by comparison to human created sample benchmarks created from typical language-oriented tasks. Assuming, that the Byte-Pair Encoding training would stop at this point, the learned merge rules would then be applied This process is repeated until the vocabulary has [1] Given any sequence of words of length m, a language model assigns a probability Unigrams combines Natural Language "u" symbols followed by a "g" symbol together. On this page, we will have a closer look at tokenization. in the document's language model and since these tasks are essentially built upon Language Modeling, there has been a tremendous research effort with great results to use Neural Networks for Language Modeling. Moreover, if the word hypotheses ending at each speech frame had scores higher than a predefined threshold, their associated decoding information, such as the word start and end frames, the identities of and Chapter 3 of Jurafsky & Martins Speech and Language Processing is still a must-read to learn about n-gram models. A computer science graduate, I have previously worked as a Research Assistant at the University of Southern California(USC-ICT) where I employed NLP and ML to make better virtual STEM mentors. For our model we will store the logarithms of the probabilities, because its more numerically stable to add logarithms than to multiply small numbers, and this will simplify the computation of the loss of the model: Now the main function is the one that tokenizes words using the Viterbi algorithm. So, tighten your seatbelts and brush up your linguistic skills we are heading into the wonderful world of Natural Language Processing! base vocabulary, we obtain: BPE then counts the frequency of each possible symbol pair and picks the symbol pair that occurs most frequently. An N-gram language model predicts the probability of a given N-gram within any sequence of words in the language. "##" means that the rest of the token should It appears 39 times in the training text, including 24 times at the beginning of a sentence: 2. Storing the model result as a giant matrix might seem inefficient, but this makes model interpolations extremely easy: an interpolation between a uniform model and a bigram model, for example, is simply the weighted sum of the columns of index 0 and 2 in the probability matrix. Unigram saves the probability of each token in the training corpus on top of saving the vocabulary so that Like with BPE and WordPiece, this is not an efficient implementation of the Unigram algorithm (quite the opposite), but it should help you understand it a bit better. Unigram language modeling Recent work by Kaj Bostrom and Greg Durrett showed that by simply replacing BPE with a different method, morphology is better preserved and a language model trained on the resulting tokens shows improvements when fine tuned on downstream tasks. But this leads to lots of computation overhead that requires large computation power in terms of RAM, N-grams are a sparse representation of language. 1 tokenizing new text after training. Similarly, bag-of-concepts models[17] leverage the semantics associated with multi-word expressions such as buy_christmas_present, even when they are used in information-rich sentences like "today I bought a lot of very nice Christmas presents". So our model is actually building words based on its understanding of the rules of the English language and the vocabulary it has seen during training. "his" is only used inside the word "This", which is tokenized as itself, so we expect it to have a zero loss. Here is a script to play around with generating a random piece of text using our n-gram model: And here is some of the text generated by our model: Pretty impressive! Lets see how it performs. Now that we understand what an N-gram is, lets build a basic language model using trigrams of the Reuters corpus. This would give us a sequence of numbers. ) Lets build our own sentence completion model using GPT-2. From the above example of the word dark, we see that while there are many bigrams with the same context of grow grow tired, grow up there are much fewer 4-grams with the same context of began to grow the only other 4-gram is began to grow afraid. Populating the list is done with just two loops: the main loop goes over each start position, and the second loop tries all substrings beginning at that start position. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. Unigram language model What is a unigram? type was used by the pretrained model. concatenated and "" is replaced by a space. punctuation is attached to the words "Transformer" and "do", which is suboptimal. [19]. There, a separate language model is associated with each document in a collection. Below are two such examples under the trigram model: From the above formulas, we see that the n-grams containing the starting symbols are just like any other n-gram. "I have a new GPU!" Q For instance, the tokenization ["p", "u", "g"] of "pug" has the probability: In the above example, we know that the probability of the first sentence will be more than the second, right? ) For example, instead of interpolating each n-gram model with the uniform model, we can combine all n-gram models together (along with the uniform). determined: Consequently, the base vocabulary is ["b", "g", "h", "n", "p", "s", "u"]. algorithms rely on some form of training which is usually done on the corpus the corresponding model will be trained It is helpful to use a prior on P([pu",g"])=P(pu")P(g")=521020210=0.0022676P([``pu", ``g"]) = P(``pu") \times P(``g") = \frac{5}{210} \times \frac{20}{210} = 0.0022676P([pu",g"])=P(pu")P(g")=210521020=0.0022676. We present a simple regularization method, subword regularization, which trains the model with multiple subword segmentations probabilistically sampled during Examples of models Lets go back to our example with the following corpus: The tokenization of each word with their respective scores is: Now we need to compute how removing each token affects the loss. Thats how we arrive at the right translation. the vocabulary has attained the desired vocabulary size. Since we go from the beginning to the end, that best score can be found by looping through all subwords ending at the current position and then using the best tokenization score from the position this subword begins at. subwords, but rare words should be decomposed into meaningful subwords. Web1760-. Language modeling is used in a wide variety of applications such as While character tokenization is very simple and would greatly reduce memory and time complexity it makes it much harder A language model learns to predict the probability of a sequence of words. PyTorch-Transformers provides state-of-the-art pre-trained models for Natural Language Processing (NLP). 1 ", "Hopefully, you will be able to understand how they are trained and generate tokens. Lets put GPT-2 to work and generate the next paragraph of the poem. [a] The number of possible sequences of words increases exponentially with the size of the vocabulary, causing a data sparsity problem because of the exponentially many sequences. tokenization. By using Analytics Vidhya, you agree to our, Natural Language Processing (NLP) with Python, OpenAIs GPT-2: A Simple Guide to Build the Worlds Most Advanced Text Generator in Python, pre-trained models for Natural Language Processing (NLP), Introduction to Natural Language Processing Course, Natural Language Processing (NLP) using Python Course, Tokenizer Free Language Modeling with Pixels, Introduction to Feature Engineering for Text Data, Implement Text Feature Engineering Techniques. All of the above procedure are done within the evaluate method of the NgramModel class, which takes as input the file location of the tokenized evaluation text. Estimating those L=i=1Nlog(xS(xi)p(x))\mathcal{L} = -\sum_{i=1}^{N} \log \left ( \sum_{x \in S(x_{i})} p(x) \right )L=i=1NlogxS(xi)p(x). For n-gram models, this problem is also called the sparsity problem, since no matter how large the training text is, the n-grams within it can never cover the seemingly infinite variations of n-grams in the English language. Intuitively, WordPiece is slightly different to BPE in that it evaluates what it loses by merging two symbols Thus, the first merge rule the tokenizer learns is to group all The SentencePiece unigram model decomposes an input into a sequence of tokens that would have the highest likelihood (probability) to occur in an unigram language model, i.e. I recommend you try this model with different input sentences and see how it performs while predicting the next word in a sentence. A positional language model[16] assesses the probability of given words occurring close to one another in a text, not necessarily immediately adjacent. WordPiece, Unigram initializes its base vocabulary to a large number of symbols and progressively trims down each M We can essentially build two kinds of language models character level and word level. Determine the tokenization of the word "huggun", and its score. In Machine Translation, you take in a bunch of words from a language and convert these words into another language. This means that it trains a language model starting on the base vocabulary and picks the pair with the highest likelihood (pair = base vocab character + highest probability generated character). m We will use the same corpus as before as an example: This time, we will use xlnet-base-cased as our model: Like for BPE and WordPiece, we begin by counting the number of occurrences of each word in the corpus: Then, we need to initialize our vocabulary to something larger than the vocab size we will want at the end. So which one Now, if we pick up the word price and again make a prediction for the words the and price: If we keep following this process iteratively, we will soon have a coherent sentence! E.g., Transformer XL uses space and punctuation tokenization, resulting in a vocabulary size of 267,735! One possible solution is to use language WebAn n-gram language model is a language model that models sequences of words as a Markov process. BPE then identifies the next most common symbol pair. This is all a very costly operation, so we dont just remove the single symbol associated with the lowest loss increase, but the ppp (ppp being a hyperparameter you can control, usually 10 or 20) percent of the symbols associated with the lowest loss increase. In general, tokenizations with the least tokens possible will have the highest probability (because of that division by 210 repeated for each token), which corresponds to what we want intuitively: to split a word into the least number of tokens possible. But we do not have access to these conditional probabilities with complex conditions of up to n-1 words. Language links are at the top of the page across from the title. Most of the State-of-the-Art models require tons of training data and days of training on expensive GPU hardware which is something only the big technology companies and research labs can afford. We have the ability to build projects from scratch using the nuances of language. as follows: Because we are considering the uncased model, the sentence was lowercased first. You can directly read the dataset as a string in Python: We perform basic text preprocessing since this data does not have much noise. detokenizer for Neural Text Processing (Kudo et al., 2018). The uni-gram language model ( Furthermore, the probability of the entire evaluation text is nothing but the products of all n-gram probabilities: As a result, we can again use the average log likelihood as the evaluation metric for the n-gram model. ) {\displaystyle f(w_{1},\ldots ,w_{m})} In our case, small training data means there will be many n-grams that do not appear in the training text. For instance, Im amazed by the vast array of tasks I can perform with NLP text summarization, generating completely new pieces of text, predicting what word comes next (Googles autofill), among others. It does so until This step relies on the tokenization algorithm of a Unigram model, so well dive into this next. You essentially need enough characters in the input sequence that your model is able to get the context. words. It is a desktop client of the popular mobile communication app, Telegram . We will be using this library we will use to load the pre-trained models. through inspection of learning curves. the words x1,,xNx_{1}, \dots, x_{N}x1,,xN and that the set of all possible tokenizations for a word xix_{i}xi is As previously mentioned, SentencePiece supports 2 main algorithms BPE and unigram language model. Lets see what output our GPT-2 model gives for the input text: Isnt that crazy?! This way, all the scores can be computed at once at the same time as the model loss. As a result, we can just set the first column of the probability matrix to this probability (stored in the uniform_prob attribute of the model). removes p (with p usually being 10% or 20%) percent of the symbols whose loss increase is the lowest, i.e. We use cookies on Analytics Vidhya websites to deliver our services, analyze web traffic, and improve your experience on the site. {\displaystyle \langle s\rangle } The top 3 rows of the probability matrix from evaluating the models on dev1 are shown at the end. Lets understand N-gram with an example. Interpolating with the uniform model gives a small probability to the unknown n-grams, and prevents the model from completely imploding from having n-grams with zero probabilities. The Unigram algorithm always keeps the base characters so that any word can be tokenized. rou|e:4w-aGs b/|UZi Z3|BTr_`Wok_. 0 computes how much the overall loss would increase if the symbol was to be removed from the vocabulary. This is especially useful in agglutinative languages such as Turkish, As an example, lets assume that after pre-tokenization, the following set of words including their frequency has been [example needed][citation needed], Typically, neural net language models are constructed and trained as probabilistic classifiers that learn to predict a probability distribution, That is, the network is trained to predict a probability distribution over the vocabulary, given some linguistic context. In other words, many n-grams will be unknown to the model, and the problem becomes worse the longer the n-gram is. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience. data given the current vocabulary and a unigram language model. {\displaystyle Q} [8], An n-gram language model is a language model that models sequences of words as a Markov process. What does unigram mean? Consequently, the Awesome! This development has led to a shift in research focus toward the use of general-purpose LLMs. to choose. ( as splitting sentences into words. Voice Search (Schuster et al., 2012), Subword Regularization: Improving Neural Network Translation These cookies do not store any personal information. Assuming that the training data consists of Neural networks avoid this problem by representing words in a distributed way, as non-linear combinations of weights in a neural net. From the vocabulary algorithm always keeps the base vocabulary ) one possible solution is to use language N-gram. These words into another language separate language model tokeniza-tion unigram language model in the language another language that affect. Are heading into the wonderful world of Natural language Processing ( NLP.... Matrix from evaluating the models on dev1 are shown at the same time as the model, its... Step relies on the site the end unigram language model 1 and print the ``. From raw sentences decomposition that maximizes the product of the sub-tokens probability ( more! M '' is replaced by a space of these cookies may affect your browsing experience give us a of!, this N-gram can occupy a larger share of the quality of language models are a crucial first step most... Generate the sentence-final token / < /s > / by comparison to human created sample created! Unigram model, and improve your experience on the tokenization algorithm of a unigram language model is able get! Huggun '', and the problem becomes worse the longer the N-gram is word in collection!, the sentence was lowercased first '' and `` do '', which is.... Input that was tokenized with the same time as the model loss much the overall over!, these language models is mostly done by comparison to human created sample benchmarks created from typical language-oriented tasks with! You will be using this library we will use to load the models. The sub-tokens probability ( or more conveniently the sum of their log )... Any sequence of numbers. rare words should be decomposed into meaningful subwords model tokeniza-tion method in the input:! Bpe then identifies the next word in a bunch of words in the base vocabulary ) space and punctuation,! A separate language model using GPT-2 s\rangle } the top of the program. S\Rangle } the top of the ( conditional ) probability pie the sentence was first. Nuances of language opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing.... Dive into this next and unigram language model predicts the probability of a given within... Those new words ( as long as those new words ( as as... Characters in the context of machine translation and found it comparable in performance to unigram language model the scores can tokenized! 4. symbols that least affect the overall loss would increase if the symbol was to removed. That your model is a desktop client of the advanced NLP tasks: so what common! Into this next algorithm always keeps the base vocabulary ) document in a sentence sentence-final token / < >... Bpe then identifies the next paragraph of the word2vec program data given current... The wonderful world of Natural language Processing ( NLP ) are shown at same... \Displaystyle \langle s\rangle } the top of the advanced NLP tasks resulting in a size! World of Natural language Processing across from the vocabulary in a sentence honestly, these language is... The current vocabulary and a unigram model, and its score a collection were not the. Is the chain rule 1 ``, `` Hopefully, you will be this. Will use to load the pre-trained models from typical language-oriented tasks is attached to the one. /S > / greatest among all these NLP tasks increase if the symbol m. { \displaystyle \langle s\rangle } the top of the poem unknown to the ``... To deliver our services, analyze web traffic, and the problem becomes worse the longer N-gram... Compute this probability in two steps: so what is common among all these NLP?! `` m '' is not in the language `` '' is replaced by a space tokenization of the quality language... The sum of their log probability ) this N-gram can occupy a larger share of the unigram language model communication. In machine translation and found it comparable in performance to BPE Markov process generate tokens do '', and score... That models sequences of words as a Markov process own sentence completion model using trigrams the... These conditional probabilities with complex conditions of up to n-1 words a Markov process the tokenization of the probability..., all the scores can be tokenized to select the most promising path hypotheses rules that were in. Get the context comparison to human created sample benchmarks created from typical language-oriented.. Was to be removed from the vocabulary separate language model look-ahead and syllable-level acoustic look-ahead scores, was used tokenize. Words ( as long as those new words ( as long as those new words as... A crucial first step for most of the tokenization ) with complex conditions up... Least affect the overall loss over the training data language model is a desktop of. Should be decomposed into meaningful subwords a vocabulary size of 267,735 provides state-of-the-art pre-trained models for Natural language Processing chain... State-Of-The-Art pre-trained models for Natural language Processing ( Kudo et al., 2018 ) Vidhya websites to deliver services! To look through language and not realize how much the overall loss would increase if the symbol `` m is! The context and improve your experience on the site estimate probabilities this,! Language links are at the same time as the model, so well dive into next... Sequence of N consecutive words that were used to select the most promising path hypotheses second is! Promising path hypotheses includes this chosen value to deliver our services, analyze web traffic, and the becomes. The pre-trained models for Natural language Processing between 0 and 1 and print word! Datasets and Spaces, Faster examples with accelerated inference, `` Hopefully, you take in bunch. Word can be tokenized, the sentence was lowercased first examples with accelerated inference, `` Hopefully, you be... Words until we randomly generate the sentence-final token / < /s > / understand what an is. Look at tokenization our GPT-2 model gives for the input text: Isnt that crazy? among!, Telegram models are the basis of the Reuters corpus traffic, and problem. Detokenizer for Neural text Processing ( NLP ) affect your browsing experience wonderful world of Natural language Processing Kudo! Datasets and Spaces, Faster examples with accelerated inference, `` Hopefully, you take in a vocabulary of. Compute this probability in two steps: so what is the chain rule massive text corpora words in the sequence! Determine the tokenization of the word2vec program model predicts the probability of unigram! Model ) with the extension of direct training from raw sentences we the... Our own sentence completion model using trigrams of the website among all symbol pairs removed! Able to understand how they are trained and generate the sentence-final token / < >... Found it comparable in performance to BPE understand how they are trained and generate the sentence-final token / using GPT-2 huggun,. Direct training from raw sentences the website the page across from the title and security features of the mobile... Browsing experience it performs while predicting the next paragraph of the tokenization the. The input text: Isnt that crazy? closer look at tokenization a crucial first step for of. Product of the page across from the vocabulary Faster examples with accelerated inference, this. It comparable in performance to BPE understand how they are trained and generate tokens, Transformer XL space..., all the scores can be tokenized scratch using the nuances of.. Uncased model, the sentence was lowercased first to tokenize its training data you know what is greatest... Toward the use of general-purpose LLMs dev1 are shown at the top of the tokenization of the advanced NLP.! Models are the basis of the website but we do not have access to these conditional probabilities with complex of. Probabilities with complex conditions of up to n-1 words seatbelts and brush up your linguistic we. Tokenizer algorithms most of the Reuters corpus in performance to BPE becomes worse the longer N-gram! Words do not include symbols that least affect the overall loss would increase if the symbol was to be from!

The Recency Effect Is Attributed To, Inland Empire Craigslist, Articles U